Selling a house in Colonial Heights typically costs the seller about 1.9% of the sale price in government transfer taxes, before commission, attorney fees and prorations. The City of Yonkers charges 1.5% and New York State charges 0.4%. On a home that sells at the neighborhood's recent median of $865,000, that is roughly $16,400 in transfer taxes alone. Knowing that number before you list is the difference between pricing with confidence and being surprised at the closing table.
I live in Colonial Heights and sell here, and the most common question I get from neighbors is not "what is my house worth" but "what will I actually walk away with." This article answers the second question.
The two transfer taxes every Yonkers seller pays
Yonkers is one of the few places in Westchester County with its own city transfer tax, and it is the largest single government cost in a Colonial Heights sale.
City of Yonkers transfer tax: 1.5%. According to the City of Yonkers, "this tax is 1.5% of the selling price" and "the seller is required to pay the tax." There are two notable exceptions. Sales of $25,000 or less owe nothing, and sales of co-op units are exempt from the city tax altogether. For a single-family colonial or Tudor, which describes most of Colonial Heights, the full 1.5% applies.
New York State transfer tax: 0.4%. The state charges 0.4% of the sale price, paid by the seller. According to the NYS Department of Taxation and Finance, the price is rounded up to the nearest $500 before the rate is applied.
Together that is 1.9%. Here is what it looks like at three price points I see regularly in the neighborhood:
| Sale price | Yonkers city tax (1.5%) | NYS tax (0.4%) | Total transfer taxes |
|---|---|---|---|
| $725,000 | $10,875 | $2,900 | $13,775 |
| $865,000 | $12,975 | $3,460 | $16,435 |
| $1,250,000 | $18,750 | $5,000 | $23,750 |
One thing to keep in mind: sellers who live a few blocks over in Bronxville or Tuckahoe do not pay the Yonkers city tax. When you compare your net to a friend's sale in a neighboring village, this is usually the gap.
The rest of the seller's side of the closing statement
Transfer taxes are fixed by law. The remaining costs vary by home and by agreement, and each one deserves a line in your estimate.
Brokerage commission. Commission is negotiable and is set in your listing agreement. Since the 2024 changes to how buyer-agent compensation is handled, sellers decide separately whether to offer anything toward the buyer's agent. I walk every seller through those choices in writing before they sign, so there is no ambiguity about what comes out of the proceeds.
Seller's attorney. New York closings are run by attorneys. Most Westchester attorneys charge a flat fee for a residential sale that covers contract negotiation and the closing. Ask for a written quote before you list.
Mortgage payoff. Your lender's payoff letter will include the remaining principal, interest through the closing date and any recording or processing fees for the satisfaction of mortgage.
Property tax proration. Most Colonial Heights homeowners pay between $12,000 and $22,000 a year in property taxes. At closing, taxes are adjusted so you pay only for the time you owned the home. Depending on where you are in the tax calendar, this can be a credit to you or a charge.
Water and sewer. A final meter reading is ordered before closing and the balance is settled from your proceeds.
Preparation costs. Pre-listing repairs, painting, staging and cleaning are paid before closing. They are optional, but in my experience they are the costs that pay for themselves most reliably.
What sellers do not pay. New York's mansion tax, 1% on residential purchases of $1 million or more, is the buyer's cost. Title insurance for the buyer's policy and the buyer's mortgage recording tax are also on the buyer's side.
A worked example at the Colonial Heights median
Here is a simplified estimate for a single-family home that sells for $865,000, owned free of complications, with a mid-range tax bill. Commission is shown as a placeholder because it is set by each seller's agreement.
| Line item | Estimate |
|---|---|
| Sale price | $865,000 |
| Yonkers transfer tax (1.5%) | −$12,975 |
| NYS transfer tax (0.4%) | −$3,460 |
| Seller's attorney | −$2,500 to −$3,500 |
| Brokerage commission | Per listing agreement |
| Mortgage payoff | Per lender payoff letter |
| Tax and utility adjustments | Credit or charge at closing |
Even before commission and payoff, the fixed government and legal costs land near $19,000 to $20,000. That is why I never quote a list price without a net number next to it.
What this means for sellers in Colonial Heights
The local market supports sellers who price accurately. Across Yonkers, homes sold in September 2026 at a median of $649,691, up 8.8% from a year earlier, with a median of 36 days on market and a sale-to-list ratio of 101.2%, according to Redfin. Colonial Heights sits well above the citywide median, at about $865,000 in recent sales, because buyers pay for the streets, the housing stock and the commute to Grand Central.
In my experience working with sellers here, the costs above rarely change the decision to sell. What they change is the strategy. A seller who knows the net early can decide calmly whether to invest in preparation, how much negotiating room to keep, and what price actually meets their goal. A seller who learns the numbers at contract tends to negotiate defensively.
How to use this to protect your proceeds
- Get a written net sheet before you choose a list price. Your number should start from comparable sales on your street, not a citywide average, and subtract every line above.
- Ask your accountant about capital gains early. Many long-time owners qualify for the federal home-sale exclusion, but improvements, rentals and time in the home all matter. A short call before listing avoids surprises in April.
- Spend on preparation where buyers notice. Paint, lighting, landscaping and a deep clean usually return more than they cost. Full renovations right before a sale usually do not.
- Pull your documents now. Your deed, survey, certificates of occupancy for any additions, and recent tax and water bills. Missing paperwork is the most common cause of a delayed Yonkers closing.
- Check the calendar. Where you close in the tax year changes your proration. It is worth knowing before you agree to a closing date.
If you would like a written net-proceeds estimate for your home, I prepare one for every Colonial Heights homeowner at no cost, along with a comparative market analysis from live MLS data.
Sources: City of Yonkers, Real Estate Transfer Tax; NYS Department of Taxation and Finance, real estate transfer tax; Redfin, Yonkers Housing Market, September 2026 data. This article is general information and not legal or tax advice; confirm figures with your attorney and accountant.
Frequently asked questions
Who pays the transfer tax when you sell a house in Yonkers?
The seller does. The City of Yonkers charges a real estate transfer tax of 1.5% of the selling price, and New York State charges 0.4%, for a combined 1.9% on a typical Colonial Heights house sale.
Do co-op sellers in Yonkers pay the city transfer tax?
No. According to the City of Yonkers, sales of co-op units are not required to pay the city transfer tax. Co-op sellers still owe the New York State transfer tax and should check whether their building charges a flip tax.
How much are seller closing costs in Westchester County?
In Yonkers, government transfer taxes alone come to about 1.9% of the sale price. Add the seller's attorney fee, brokerage commission as set in your listing agreement, prorated property taxes and any mortgage payoff fees to get your full number.
Does the seller pay the mansion tax in New York?
No. New York's mansion tax applies to residential purchases of $1 million or more and is paid by the buyer, so it does not come out of the seller's proceeds.
How do I estimate my net proceeds from selling my home in Yonkers?
Start with a realistic sale price from recent comparable sales, then subtract the 1.9% in transfer taxes, your mortgage payoff, attorney fee, commission and prorated taxes. Rafael Barbosa prepares a written net-proceeds estimate for every Colonial Heights seller before the home is listed.

