If you are selling a home in Colonial Heights, price it against recent Colonial Heights and east Yonkers sales, not against Bronxville or Tuckahoe, and treat that neighboring location as a marketing advantage rather than a pricing basis. Buyers and their appraisers will compare your house to Yonkers sales. According to Redfin, the median sale price in Yonkers was $649,691 in September 2026, up 8.8% from a year earlier, with homes selling at 101.2% of list price. A plan built on those comps, then marketed on location, is how Colonial Heights sellers protect their number.
Why Colonial Heights Gets Compared to Bronxville and Tuckahoe
Colonial Heights sits in the northeast corner of Yonkers, bordered by Bronxville and Tuckahoe. The streets look and feel like their neighbors: center-hall colonials, Tudors and capes on curving, tree-lined blocks such as Bradford Boulevard and Alta Vista Drive, with co-op and condo buildings along Colonial Parkway. Many households use the Bronxville or Tuckahoe Metro-North stations on the Harlem Line, roughly 30 to 35 minutes to Grand Central on an express train. Our Colonial Heights neighborhood guide covers the streets and housing styles in more detail.
That proximity is real, and it is valuable. But the legal and financial facts of a Colonial Heights home are Yonkers facts. The address is Yonkers 10710. The property tax bill comes from the City of Yonkers, and the home is in the Yonkers school district. When a buyer's lender orders an appraisal, the appraiser will look first at closed sales in Colonial Heights and nearby east Yonkers, not at a Tudor two blocks over the village line.
This is where many sellers get tripped up. A homeowner sees a Bronxville house with a similar footprint close at a much higher price and assumes the gap is negotiable. It usually is not. Pricing a Colonial Heights home off Bronxville numbers tends to produce a listing that sits, collects price reductions, and eventually sells for less than it would have with a correct launch price.
What the Numbers Say Right Now
The price-per-square-foot data shows how wide the gap across the border is. Per Redfin, the median sale price per square foot in Yonkers was $323 over the three months through September 2026. For the Village of Bronxville over the same period, Redfin shows $688 per square foot. Village figures rest on a handful of sales, so they move sharply from month to month (Tuckahoe's recent sales were mostly smaller homes, which makes its current figure a poor comparison), but the direction in Bronxville is consistent: buyers pay a significant premium for a village address.
The more useful numbers for a Colonial Heights seller are about speed and competition in Yonkers itself. Redfin reports that 46.7% of Yonkers homes sold above list price over the three months through September 2026, while 25.7% of listings took a price cut, up 3 points from a year earlier. In other words, the market rewards homes that launch at the right number and is noticeably less patient with homes that do not.
Colonial Heights runs ahead of the citywide figures where it counts. For its Colonial Heights-Mohegan Heights area, Redfin reports a median of $429 per square foot over the three months through September 2026, up 10.0% from a year earlier and about a third above the Yonkers figure, with a median of 35 days on market. The median sale price in that period, $646,662, rests on only four sales, so it says more about which homes happened to close than about value. Price per square foot is the better guide, and it shows the premium a well-priced Colonial Heights home can capture. It is not the same as Bronxville pricing, and it does not need to be.
The Cost Side: What Yonkers Sellers Pay at Closing
Pricing is only half of the equation. What you net matters more than what you list for, and Colonial Heights sellers face one cost their village neighbors do not.
Per the City of Yonkers, the seller pays a city real estate transfer tax of 1.5% of the selling price. New York State adds its own 0.4% transfer tax (NYS Department of Taxation and Finance), for a combined 1.9%. On a $900,000 sale, that is $17,100 in transfer taxes before commission, attorney fees or any other closing cost. Co-op sales are exempt from the Yonkers city tax, so a Colonial Parkway co-op seller pays only the state portion. Sellers in Bronxville and Tuckahoe pay only the 0.4% state tax. The full list is in our guide to what it costs to sell a home in Colonial Heights.
This matters in two ways. First, it belongs in your net proceeds estimate from day one, not as a surprise at the closing table. Second, it is one more reason not to overreach on list price: every month a listing sits is another month of carrying costs on top of a transfer tax that is already fixed.
What This Means for Sellers in Colonial Heights
The Colonial Heights seller's advantage is simple: you offer the setting buyers want near Bronxville and Tuckahoe, at a price point below the villages. That value story is what fills an open house. The risk is pricing away the value story by reaching for village numbers.
I live in Colonial Heights, and in my experience working with sellers here, the homes that sell fastest and strongest share three traits. They are priced within a tight band of recent Colonial Heights comps. Their marketing leads with the walk or short drive to the Bronxville and Tuckahoe stations, the architecture and the lot. And they are prepared before the first photograph, because buyers comparing your house to a renovated Bronxville listing will notice dated paint and tired floors immediately.
Fall and early winter add one more factor. Fewer listings compete for buyers' attention between November and February, so a correctly priced Colonial Heights home can stand out. A mispriced one simply waits for spring, when it will compete against far more inventory.
How to Use This to Get Top Dollar
- Build your price from Colonial Heights comps first. Use closed sales within the neighborhood over the last six to twelve months, matched on style, square footage, lot size and condition. Use east Yonkers sales next. Use Bronxville and Tuckahoe sales only as context for the ceiling.
- Price per square foot, then adjust. A Yonkers address sells closer to Yonkers price-per-square-foot figures. Adjust up for updated kitchens and baths, finished lower levels, garages and proximity to the stations.
- Market the location without overstating it. Describe the facts: distance to the Bronxville and Tuckahoe stations, the commute to Grand Central, nearby parks and village shopping. Never imply the home is in a village or school district it is not in. Accuracy protects you during negotiation and at closing.
- Run your net proceeds before you list. Include the 1.5% Yonkers transfer tax, the 0.4% state tax, commission, attorney fees and any payoff. The net proceeds calculator does the math in a minute.
- Launch at the number, not above it. With more than a quarter of Yonkers listings taking a price cut in the latest Redfin data, the first two weeks on market are when your home draws its strongest offers.
Thinking about selling in Colonial Heights? Call or text me at 914-430-0440, or request a free home value estimate, and I will put together a pricing plan built on real Colonial Heights comps.
Sources: Redfin, Yonkers housing market (September 2026); Redfin, Colonial Heights-Mohegan Heights housing market (September 2026); Redfin, Village of Bronxville housing market (September 2026); City of Yonkers, Real Estate Transfer Tax; NYS Department of Taxation and Finance, Real estate transfer tax
Frequently asked questions
Is Colonial Heights part of Bronxville?
No. Colonial Heights is a neighborhood in the City of Yonkers with Yonkers 10710 addresses, Yonkers property taxes and the Yonkers school district. It borders Bronxville and Tuckahoe, and many residents use the Bronxville and Tuckahoe Metro-North stations, but it is not part of either village.
How much is my house worth in Colonial Heights Yonkers?
The most reliable estimate comes from recent closed sales of similar homes in Colonial Heights and east Yonkers, adjusted for size, condition and lot. For context, Redfin reported a median of $429 per square foot for its Colonial Heights-Mohegan Heights area over the three months through September 2026, versus $323 for Yonkers as a whole.
Who pays the transfer tax when selling a house in Yonkers?
The seller pays. Per the City of Yonkers, the city transfer tax is 1.5% of the selling price, and New York State adds 0.4%, for a combined 1.9%. Co-op sales are exempt from the Yonkers city portion.
Should I price my Colonial Heights home like a Bronxville home?
No. Appraisers and buyers compare a Colonial Heights home to Yonkers sales, and Redfin data for the three months through September 2026 shows Bronxville selling near $688 per square foot versus a $323 median for Yonkers. Use the location as a marketing advantage, and price from Colonial Heights comps.
How fast are homes selling in Yonkers right now?
Per Redfin, Yonkers homes had a median of 36 days on market over the three months through September 2026, and 46.7% sold above list price. Redfin's figures for the Colonial Heights-Mohegan Heights area showed a median of 35 days on market over the same period.
Is it a good time to sell a house in Colonial Heights?
Late fall and winter bring fewer competing listings, so a correctly priced Colonial Heights home can stand out to active buyers. Yonkers prices were up 8.8% year over year in September 2026, according to Redfin, which supports sellers who price accurately rather than aggressively.

