Rafael BarbosaColonial Heights · Yonkers 914-430-0440

Colonial Heights, Yonkers: A Neighborhood Guide for Homeowners and Buyers

Rafael Barbosa
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson, Compass
A quiet, tree-lined residential street in Colonial Heights, Yonkers

Colonial Heights is a neighborhood of quiet, tree-lined streets and single-family homes in northeast Yonkers, about 22 miles from Midtown Manhattan. As of October 2026, the median single-family home here sold for $865,000, roughly 3% over asking, according to OneKey MLS.

I live in Colonial Heights, and I sell homes here. This guide covers what I tell every homeowner and buyer who asks about the neighborhood: where it is, what the homes are like, how people get around and what the market is doing right now.

Where Colonial Heights is

Colonial Heights sits in northeast Yonkers, in Westchester County. Central Park Avenue runs along its western edge, the Grassy Sprain Reservoir lies to the north, and Crestwood and the Village of Tuckahoe are just to the east. The Village of Bronxville is under two miles away.

Most homes carry a 10710 ZIP code, and some use a 10707 Tuckahoe mailing address. That detail matters: a Tuckahoe mailing address does not always mean a home is in the Village of Tuckahoe. Many are in the City of Yonkers, which affects property taxes and municipal services. Always check the tax bill.

The homes

Colonial Heights is known for quiet streets of single-family homes. You will find center-hall colonials, Tudors, capes, ranches and split-levels, often on hilly lots with mature trees.

Co-op and condo buildings along and near Central Park Avenue offer a lower price point for buyers who want to be in the area without maintaining a house.

Getting around

  • Train: Metro-North Harlem Line service to Grand Central from the Crestwood and Tuckahoe stations, both a short drive away.
  • Car: Quick access to the Bronx River Parkway, Sprain Brook Parkway, Cross County Parkway and the New York State Thruway (I-87).
  • Bus: Bee-Line bus service along Central Park Avenue.

Everyday life

Central Park Avenue covers most errands, from grocery stores to services, and Cross County Center is a short drive south. For restaurants and coffee, Main Street in Tuckahoe and Columbus Avenue in Crestwood are minutes away. The Bronx River Pathway, along the Bronx River Parkway, is a popular route for walking and cycling.

The Colonial Heights market right now

Single-family homes in Colonial Heights are holding their value and still selling above asking. Here is the picture as of October 2026, according to OneKey MLS:

Single-family homes October 2026
Median sale price $865,000
Change from last year Down 0.65%
Median days on market 42 days
Average sale-to-list price 103%
Homes sold, last 90 days About 25
Active listings 5 to 6

Prices are essentially flat from last year, and the typical house still sells about 3% over asking in roughly six weeks. With only five or six houses on the market, sellers face very little competition heading into winter.

Co-ops and condos near Central Park Avenue generally sell from about $200,000 for a one-bedroom to about $475,000 for a two-bedroom, with four or five units on the market today.

What Colonial Heights sellers should know

  1. Price to your block, not the ZIP code. Values shift street by street with lot size, slope and proximity to the train. I build every price from the closest recent sales.
  2. Have your heating details ready. About a third of homes in Colonial Heights heat with fuel oil, so buyers often ask about oil tanks, their age and location. Having records on hand prevents surprises during inspection.
  3. Confirm your municipality and taxes. Because of the 10707 and 10710 overlap, buyers want to know exactly which taxes apply. Put your latest tax bill in your listing package.
  4. Lead with the commute. Train access to Grand Central and the parkways is one of the area's strongest selling points. Your marketing should say so.
  5. Co-op sellers, prepare early. Board packages take time. Gather financials and building documents before you list.

For the full picture, see how long it takes to sell a home in Colonial Heights, what it costs to sell, and my closer look at Colonial Heights housing stock and prices.

If you are thinking about selling in the next six to twelve months, I am happy to walk through your home and prepare a pricing strategy from live MLS data. Request a free home value estimate, or call or text me at 914-430-0440. Hablo español.

Sources: OneKey MLS, October 2026 data compiled by Rafael Barbosa; City-Data, Colonial Heights neighborhood profile (home heating fuel); Apartments.com, Colonial Heights area guide (location).

Frequently asked questions

Is Colonial Heights part of Yonkers?

Yes. Colonial Heights is a neighborhood in the City of Yonkers, in Westchester County, New York. Some homes use a 10707 Tuckahoe mailing address but are still within the City of Yonkers.

What ZIP code is Colonial Heights in?

Most homes in Colonial Heights are in ZIP code 10710. Some use a 10707 Tuckahoe mailing address, so check the tax bill to confirm which municipality a home is in.

How far is Colonial Heights from Manhattan?

Colonial Heights is about 22 miles from Midtown Manhattan, with Metro-North Harlem Line service to Grand Central from the nearby Crestwood and Tuckahoe stations.

What is the median home price in Colonial Heights?

According to OneKey MLS, the median sale price for a single-family home in Colonial Heights was $865,000 as of October 2026, essentially flat from a year earlier. Co-ops and condos near Central Park Avenue generally sell from about $200,000 for a one-bedroom to about $475,000 for a two-bedroom.

What types of homes are in Colonial Heights?

Mostly single-family colonials, Tudors, capes, ranches and split-levels on tree-lined streets, plus co-op and condo buildings along and near Central Park Avenue.

CallTextHome value