Colonial Heights had a quiet October. Four homes closed in the neighborhood in October 2026: a co-op at $225,000, a condo at $360,000, a single-family house at $660,000 and a two-family home at $789,000, according to OneKey MLS closed sales and public records I compiled for my October 2026 market report. Across all of Yonkers, the same month was busy, with 108 closed sales and single-family houses selling at a median of $814,500 in 29 days.
I live in Colonial Heights, so I watch every sale here closely. Here is what fall 2026 looked like and what it means if you are thinking about selling.
October 2026 in Colonial Heights
| Colonial Heights, October 2026 | Sale price |
|---|---|
| Co-op | $225,000 |
| Condo | $360,000 |
| Single-family house | $660,000 |
| Two-family home | $789,000 |
| All four sales, median | $510,000 |
| Median days on market | 97 |
Source: OneKey MLS closed sales and public records, October 2026, compiled by Rafael Barbosa. Days on market counts listed sales only.
Four sales are too few for a reliable median, and one slow month does not make a trend. What October does show is how wide the range is inside one neighborhood: the two-family home sold for more than three times the co-op. Colonial Heights is not one market. The houses on the side streets, the two-family homes and the co-op and condo buildings each draw different buyers at very different prices.
How Colonial Heights compares with the rest of Yonkers
| Yonkers, October 2026 | Closed sales | Median sale price | Median days on market |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single-family houses | 40 | $814,500 | 29 |
| Two- to four-family homes | 10 | $874,500 | 42 |
| Condos | 11 | $407,000 | 59 |
| Co-ops | 47 | $200,000 | 43 |
| All Yonkers sales | 108 | $463,125 | 43 |
Source: OneKey MLS closed sales, October 2026, compiled by Rafael Barbosa.
For a longer view, Redfin reported that Yonkers homes sold at a median of $649,691 in September 2026, up 8.8% from a year earlier, with a median of 36 days on the market and a sale-to-list ratio of 101.2%. Buyers across the city were paying full price or more for well-priced homes.
The 97-day median in Colonial Heights in October is far above the 29 days for Yonkers houses, but it comes from only four sales across four property types. It is not a sign that houses here are sitting. It is a sign of how few homes come up for sale in the neighborhood in a given month.
What this means if you own in Colonial Heights
- Low inventory works for sellers. With only a handful of sales a month, a well-prepared house in Colonial Heights has little direct competition. Buyers who want the neighborhood have few choices.
- Price from the closest sales, not the citywide median. The Yonkers median of $814,500 for houses includes very different homes in very different parts of the city. Your price should come from the most recent Colonial Heights sales of homes like yours, adjusted for size, condition and lot.
- Fall and winter can be a good time to list. Fewer listings come up in the colder months. My post on how long it takes to sell in Colonial Heights walks through the timeline stage by stage.
- Know your net before you choose a price. Houses and condos in Yonkers pay 1.9% in transfer taxes (1.5% to the City of Yonkers and 0.4% to New York State). On a $660,000 sale, that is $12,540. Co-ops pay only the 0.4% state tax. See my cost to sell guide or run your numbers with the net proceeds calculator.
For more about the neighborhood itself, from its streets and house styles to parks and transit, read my Colonial Heights neighborhood guide.
Get a written value for your Colonial Heights home
I prepare a free written pricing analysis for Colonial Heights owners, built from the most recent sales of homes like yours and a full net proceeds estimate, in English or Spanish. Call or text me at 914-430-0440, or start with a free home value estimate.
Sources: OneKey MLS closed sales and Westchester County public records, October 2026, compiled by Rafael Barbosa; Redfin, Yonkers housing market, September 2026; City of Yonkers, Real Estate Transfer Tax. Medians for small samples can change significantly from month to month. General information only, not an appraisal.
Frequently asked questions
How many homes sold in Colonial Heights in October 2026?
Four. A co-op closed at $225,000, a condo at $360,000, a single-family house at $660,000 and a two-family home at $789,000, based on OneKey MLS closed sales and public records compiled by Rafael Barbosa. Four sales are too few for a reliable median.
What do houses sell for in Colonial Heights, Yonkers?
The single-family house that closed in Colonial Heights in October 2026 sold for $660,000. Across all of Yonkers, single-family houses closed at a median of $814,500 that month. Colonial Heights prices depend heavily on the size, style and condition of the house, so a written analysis from the closest sales is the reliable guide.
How fast are homes selling in Colonial Heights?
The four October 2026 sales had a median of 97 days on the market, which reflects a slow month with very few sales. Across Yonkers, single-family houses sold in a median of 29 days in October 2026.
Is it a good time to sell in Colonial Heights?
Inventory in Colonial Heights stays low, so a well-prepared, well-priced house faces little competition, especially in fall and winter. The right timing depends on your plans and your house, and Rafael Barbosa can map it out with you.

